SATURDAY, JULY 5 2008

Is Consciousness Nothing But a Word?

Local Discussion Forums

Is Consciousness Nothing But a Word?

Bob Johnston | 04.25.08 | 11:06 AM |
0
Not yet rated
Bob Johnston's picture

I often seek out skeptics to help me sharpen my feelings, thoughts and insights about various aspects of consciousness. Here's an article I found particularly interesting and thought you might too. eSkeptic writer and psychology professor Henry D. Schlinger writes,“Consciousness” is only a word we use to refer to sometimes quite different behavioral phenomena." In this article Schlinger has suggested that most of the time what people mean by the word is our ongoing, though mostly covert, self-talk about our own public and private stimulation and behaviors.

This account may or may not be correct, but it is parsimonious because it makes very few assumptions and appeals to observable or potentially observable relationships that are consistent with experimentally established scientific principles.

"We skeptics," he writes, "find it all too easy to fault obvious pseudosciences, but when it comes to our own messy, unscientific thinking about ourselves, we’re a lot less critical. Thus, it will probably take a lot longer to realize that the conscious inner life that so fascinates us may be nothing more than a learned repertoire of verbal (and/or imaginal) behavior than it did to realize that the earth is not flat, that it is not the center of the universe, and that life on earth was not designed by a Creator."

If you want to read the entire article it can be accessed in the attachment.

Bob

DiscoverDeclareShare

Member Comments:

Submitted by Jeffery DeCelles on May 5, 2008 - 11:25am.

Schlinger apparently equates consciousness with symbolic cognition. I don't. I suspect consciousness is better descibed as the substrate of cognition, awareness, sensation, emotion.
I base this notion on empirical data derived from experiments such as the Global Consciousness Project, and personal experience with a similar mind/matter interaction tool: "PsiTrainer" by PsiGenics.com.
This area of investigation, outlined by Dean Radin in "Entangled Minds", strongly suggests a field-like phenomenon is operative, if subtle. A lack of robustness does not invalidate this data, but merely invites techniques of amplification, as optics potentiated astronomic revision.
Thanks, Bob, for bringing home the bacon, yet again.

JED

Submitted by Bob Johnston on May 7, 2008 - 5:20am.

Hi Jeffrey ~

Wonderful to hear from you again.

If I understand your position accurately, I believe my experience of consciousness correlates well with yours. My 'working hypothesis' to date is that 'pure' transtemporal consciousness preexists and is the all-encompassing all-permeating Source of all temporal cognitive contents all the way from the most minute and primal of electromagnetic vibrations 'up' through gravitation, strong and weak nuclear, and other forms of all kinds.

Warmly,

Bob

Share This Page

User login